This text is republished right here with permission from The Associated Press. This content material is shared right here as a result of the subject might curiosity Snopes readers; it doesn’t, nevertheless, signify the work of Snopes fact-checkers or editors.
SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Prosecutors and protection attorneys sketched dueling portraits of fallen Silicon Valley star Elizabeth Holmes as her trial bought underway Wednesday, alternatively portraying her as a grasping villain who faked her technique to the highest and a passionate underdog whose spent years making an attempt to shake up the well being care trade.
The 2 sides at the moment are anticipated to spend the following three months making an attempt to sway a 12-person jury impaneled to listening to the proof in a case airing allegations that Holmes used her startup, Theranos, as a scheme to appreciate her desires of changing into wealthy and as well-known as certainly one of her function fashions, late Apple co-founder Steve Jobs.
As soon as hailed as a billionaire on paper, Holmes is now dealing with a sentence of as much as 20 years if convicted of the felony costs.
Holmes’ rise and fall has already been the topic of documentaries, books and podcasts, feeding the fervor that has constructed up round a trial that has been delayed twice since she was indicted practically three years in the past. With roughly solely 75 spots obtainable for the media and basic public to look at the proceedings, individuals started to line up exterior the San Jose, California, courthouse earlier than 5 a.m. Wednesday.
After the jury was seated and U.S. District Decide Edward Davila gave his preliminary directions, federal prosecutor Robert Leach wasted little time vilifying Holmes.
He solid Holmes in a darkish mild, depicting her as a conniving entrepreneur who duped traders, clients and sufferers for years, though she knew her startup, Theranos, was practically bankrupt and its much-hyped blood-testing expertise was a flop.
“This case is about fraud, about lying and cheating to get money,” Leach stated throughout his roughly 45-minute opening assertion.
He stated the proof would present that Theranos was already in serious trouble way back to 2009, about six years after Holmes based the Palo Alto, California, firm. At that time, Leach stated, Holmes resorted to a sample of mendacity and hyperbole in an effort to idiot main media shops, rich traders reminiscent of media mogul Rupert Murdoch, well-connected Theranos board members reminiscent of former U.S. Secretaries of State George Shultz and Henry Kissinger, and clients reminiscent of Walgreens.
A number of the most damning proof could also be introduced by a former prime finance officer at Theranos who will testify that the corporate solely had $650,000 in income from 2011 by way of 2014, in keeping with Leach. But Holmes was telling traders and different those who Theranos would generate $140 million in income in 2014, Leach stated.
Holmes can be accused or promising that Theranos would be capable of rapidly check small vials of blood in a small company-designed machine named after the famed inventor Thomas Edison. Leach stated the samples had been truly despatched out to exterior events for testing utilizing standard-issue machines he described as “big” and “clunky.”
Theranos ultimately failed in 2018, a number of years after a collection of explosive tales in The Wall Avenue Journal uncovered severe flaws in its expertise and spurred regulatory investigations that shut down the testing.
The fraud dedicated by Holmes “is a fraud on Main Street and it’s a fraud in Silicon Valley,” Leach informed the jury.
Holmes’ protection crew countered with a extra heroic narrative describing her as a tireless employee who poured greater than 15 years of her life in pursuit of a sooner, cheaper and fewer invasive technique to check blood samples and display for illness.
Holmes’ lawyer, Lance Wade, argued that Holmes was merely making an attempt to wrest management of the blood-testing expertise from two dominant laboratories, Quest Diagnostics and Labcorp. “She did her best day in and day out to make Theranos successful,” Wade stated of Holmes.
Though she didn’t succeed, Wade insisted that Holmes by no means stopped believing she was on the verge of a breakthrough that may notice her ambitions. Many traders thought she would too, one of many causes that Theranos as soon as was valued at $9 billion —- with half that quantity belonging to Holmes.
“Failure is not a crime,” Wade stated. “Trying your hardest is not a crime. A failed business does not make a CEO a criminal.”
In court docket paperwork unsealed simply earlier than the trial began, Holmes’ attorneys additionally disclosed that she might take the witness stand to claim a few of her statements and actions whereas operating Theranos had been the results of “intimate partner abuse” inflicted by the corporate’s chief working officer and her secret lover, Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani.
With out going into specifics, Wade informed the jury that she believed she was bringing in “the best businessman she knew” when she employed Balwani however now realizes it was certainly one of her largest errors.
“You will learn that Mr. Balwani did not take well to people who disagreed with him,” Wade stated whereas asserting Balwani’s tempestuous habits brought about many Theranos workers to depart the corporate.
Balwani faces a number of fraud costs in a separate trial scheduled to start subsequent yr. His lawyer has denied Holmes’ allegations.
This story has been corrected with the official names of Quest Diagnostics and Labcorp.